Skip to Content
Advertisement
Recipes

Chicken Swimming in Lemon & Garlic

A variation on the famous dish from Rao's in New York City that adds pucker and punch from extra lemon and garlic.

10:00 AM EDT on July 6, 2023

I've never been to Rao's, the legendary Italian restaurant in East Harlem that is infamous for the next-to-impossible reservation to snag. I've never even tried the jarred sauce they sell because I don't use jarred sauce. What I have had, too many times to count, is my own version of one the restaurant's signature dishes: Lemon Chicken.

My interpretation is pretty true to the original, though over the years, with lots of tinkering, I've come to believe that adding more lemon and more garlic, while also using only chicken thighs, as opposed to a whole bird broken down into 8 pieces, takes the power of this dish to another level.

Plus, it makes more sauce for soaking up with crusty bread.

Try my recipe, and if you ever get into Rao's, take the lemon chicken and let me know which version you prefer.

Chicken Swimming in Lemon & Garlic

Chicken Swimming in Lemon & Garlic

Recipe by Andrew Cotto
0.0 from 0 votes
Servings

4

servings
Prep time

20

minutes
Cooking time

25

minutes

Ingredients

  • 8 8 chicken thighs (bone-in, skin-on)

  • 2 2 -1/2 cups fresh lemon juice

  • 1 cup 1 extra virgin olive oil + 2 tbs

  • 6 tbs 6 minced garlic

  • 1 tbs 1 red wine vinegar

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 minced flat leaf parsley

  • salt & pepper to taste

Directions

  • Pre-heat the broiler.
  • Trim the chicken thighs of excessive fat and sinew.
  • Season to taste with salt & pepper.
  • Put the chicken, skin-side up, on a baking sheet that has been coated with 2 tbs of olive oil.
  • Put the baking sheet under the broiler for 8-10 minutes (making sure the skin does not burn).
  • Add the garlic and vinegar to the lemon juice.
  • When the chicken skin is crispy, turn over the thighs and allow to broil for 4-5 minutes.
  • Whisk the olive oil into the lemon mixture.
  • When the bottoms of the thighs are browned, turn them back over to skin-side up.
  • Cover the thighs with the lemon mixture and return to the broiler for 4-5 more minutes.
  • Remove the chicken thighs from the oven and keep covered on a platter.
  • Return the baking pan to under the broiler and allow the sauce to thicken for five minutes.
  • Remove the baking pan and pour the sauce over the chicken.
  • Sprinkle with the minced parsley.
  • Serve with lots of crusty bread to soak up the sauce.

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @appetitomagazine on Instagram and hashtag it with #italianfoodanddrink

Like this recipe?

Follow @Appetitomagazine on Pinterest

Follow us on Facebook!

Follow us on Facebook

More Stories

Appetito’s Andrew Cotto Makes Spaghetti Pomodoro for a Cause

Watch Appetito's EIC Andrew Cotto make spaghetti pomodoro to share and discuss with Italian television star Ornella Fado.

November 19, 2026

Scamorza-Stuffed Mushrooms for a Thanksgiving Appetizer

Joanna Moeller shares an elegant stuffed mushroom appetizer recipe for Thanksgiving featuring scamorza cheese from Lioni Latticini.

November 19, 2026

The Italian Art of Play: Why We Need More Fun in Our Lives

Italian-inspired ways to bring more joy, spontaneity and play into your everyday routine.

November 19, 2026

Pizza Scima: Abruzzo’s Traditional Flatbread

A trip to Abruzzo takes Erica D’Arcangelo from the steel pans of her family’s pizzeria back to the bread her ancestors baked under embers.

November 19, 2026

Knight in Shining Armor Not Needed—Donatella Cinelli Colombini’s Tuscan Winery

A call to hire a cellar master led her to the women other Tuscan wineries had overlooked.

November 19, 2026

“My Big Loud Italian Christmas” by Appetito’s Erica D’Arcangelo

This novel about an Italian family’s Feast of the Seven Fishes makes the perfect stocking stuffer.

November 18, 2026