Skip to Content
Features

The Secret to the Sauce of Michael’s of Brooklyn

Our Editor-in-Chief swings by Michael's of Brooklyn for a holiday box and is reminded of the qualities that define their excellence.

The sauces of Michael's of Brooklyn and made on site and shipped nationwide.

The sauces of Michael’s of Brooklyn and made on site and shipped nationwide.

I cut my teeth as a food writer as a regular contributor to a former column in The New York Times called “Neighborhood Joint.” I wrote a lot of these, I’m told more than anyone else, because I loved using my descriptions and storytelling skills to capture the magic of certain establishments, to help portray what keeps the owners and staff motivated and the customers satisfied.

I’ve taken this same approach to the features I’ve written here at Appetito, and I was recently reminded of this when I swung by Michael's of Brooklyn, a third-generation family institution, to talk about our upcoming promotional series. The essence of what I’m getting at when championing places like Michael’s was captured in these lines from the article linked above:

All that said about the superior cuisine, what defines the Michael's of Brooklyn experience is the aforementioned hospitality and ambiance. It's just one of those joints where you walk in — first time or regular — and know that the people who run the place and work there are passionately invested in all the best reasons people dedicate their lives to the restaurant business. They don't give a shit about Instagram. They care about people. They are devoted to the same ethos of providing an experience you can't get at home and making it all worth your while. This is why we go out to eat.

The exterior of Michael's of Brooklyn.
The exterior of Michael's of Brooklyn. Photo by Anthony Sciarratta.

I believe that the experience of eating out is collectively informed by the disparate elements of a restaurant (food, service, ambiance, etc.) working collectively to provide an impression that is singular. For example, I’m going to less enjoy the house specialty of hipster joint #72 when the Gen Zerver tells me, in a room that is way too noisy, that my guests and I have 90 minutes to eat and a one-bottle of wine maximum per two people. Fuck that. Sorry, I digress…

Now, back to Michael’s. I’d argue that the superiority of experience can extend into products produced by the same type of establishment. Case in point: The line of jarred pasta sauces from Michael’s of Brooklyn. The fourth-generation recipe from the restaurant found its way into jars back in 2006. Now they offer six red sauce variations, an Alfredo and a Vodka sauce (respectively on the latter two). It’s a big operation, reaching most of America and sites overseas, but the sauce still tastes homemade and is well-established as a standout in the crowded jarred sauce field due to elevated flavors derived from minimum ingredients.

The Platinum Pack holiday box from Michael's of Brooklyn.
The Platinum Pack holiday box from Michael's of Brooklyn.

We are going to soon document the sauce making process and delivery, as well as exploring the other aspects that make Michael’s of Brooklyn so special. For now, I encourage sending your Italian-food loving family and friends one of the Michael’s of Brooklyn holiday boxes. There are three tiers: Dinner & Dessert Pack ($65), Premium Pack ($90), and the Platinum Pack ($200). Oh, and just in case you are wondering what to get me, I'm a Platinum guy...

More on Michael’s soon!

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Appetito

Monteverde’s Chef Bailey Sullivan on Atipica Italian Cooking in Chicago

From Top Chef to one of America’s most celebrated Italian kitchens, Monteverde Executive Chef Bailey Sullivan discusses her approach to Italian cooking.

A Tavola Non Si Invecchia: Why Italians Never Rush the Table

Time at the table is not counted—it is set aside.

May 11, 2026

Sunday Shop: Four NYC Restaurants to Book in May 

Morgan Hines seeks out the best in not only food and drink but style, housewares, and more. Welcome to Appetito’s Sunday Shop!

May 10, 2026

Clementina Brings Gluten Free Italian Dining to San Francisco

The new San Francisco trattoria is rethinking what authentic Italian dining can look like for families navigating celiac disease.

Mother’s Day at Home: Favorite Italian Brunch Recipes

Skip the crowded brunch spots this year and bring the celebration home with Italian inspired dishes.

Add Style to the Menu with this ‘Devil Wears Prada’-Inspired Crimson Silk Cocktail

For those looking to bring a bit of “Runway”-level glamour to their own bar cart, Riunite shares its Crimson Silk recipe with Appetito.

May 7, 2026
See all posts