Skip to Content
News

Is Halloween Pizza a Thing Now?

Social media seems to have created a monster that's pizza shaped and occasionally topped with shocking ingredients. Here are some of the best of what we've found.

1:08 PM EDT on October 30, 2023

papa john's jack-o-lantern pizza

Papa John’s Jack-‘O-Lantern Halloween pizza.

First, the onset of fall became synonymous with the onset of pumpkin spice. Now, another connection is being made: Halloween and pizza. Is it a trend? Perhaps, or maybe not, but Appetito has spotted a few respectable pizza makers posting Halloween-themed pizzas on social media, and Papa John's has generated both interest and controversy with its Jack-'O-Lantern pizza, which it launched back in 2019 and has brought back for another run this season. (That launch provided fodder for food bloggers and others who found that the pizzas sometimes came out looking much different than what Papa John's intended.)

Scroll down below for several interesting Halloween Pizza ideas sourced from searching through social media. We've found pizzas that tried to incorporate seasonal and Halloween-related ingredients, as well as others that attempt to capture the spirit of Halloween in a pizza.

Our friend Ciro Iovine at Song e Napule is getting in the spirit with a cleverly designed Halloween Pizza.
The Italian-run Hudson Valley cidery Westwind Orchard makes excellent pizzas year-round. Their Halloween Pizza is more conceptual but sounds delicious nonetheless!
Last year, Scottish home pizzailo @dough.the.evolution created a Ghostbusters-themed pie with serious pizza-making skills behind it.
London-based pizza pop-up Rene's Pizza Place got creative with the cheese with this recent Halloween Pizza entry.
Another home pizzaola, @manopasto from Munich, Germany, created a whole series of Halloween Pizzas. Scroll through for some wild ideas.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More Stories

Italian Flavors Meet the Mediterranean at LIBA in Brooklyn

Chef Maayan Glass brings Italian touches and wide-ranging influences to one of the city’s newest dining rooms.

September 18, 2026

How to Watch “The Forgotten Feast” Documentary on YouTube

Appetito shares the documentary film "The Forgotten Feast" which pays tribute to the effort of the restaurants of Little Italy after 9/11.

September 18, 2026

The Big Apple’s Rival: A Guide to Dining in Cleveland’s Little Italy

Three longtime favorites serve up pasta, pastries and gelato along Mayfield Road.

September 18, 2026

The Perfect Gluten-Free Day in Boston

Come hungry because Boston has gluten-free plans for you.

September 18, 2026

‘Tis the Season for Smashed Figs with Prosciutto, Cheese & Honey

This seasonal fig recipe combines sweet and savory ingredients for dynamic flavor and a beautiful presentation.

September 17, 2026

Finding La Dolce Vita in New Jersey

How a trip to Italy made me realize it was never about the destination.

September 17, 2026