Skip to Content
Features

Some Chicken Parm Recs for a NY Yankees Star

Two NYC eateries that specialize in chicken parmesan are recommended to Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe for professional purposes.

Anthony Volpe batting for the New York Yankees during the 2024 MLB Little League Classic. Photo by Jeffrey Hyde (wikimedia commons).

Anthony Volpe batting for the New York Yankees during the 2024 MLB Little League Classic. Photo by Jeffrey Hyde (wikimedia commons).

Did you hear the one about the breakout baseball player fueled by chicken parm?

It’s a story on my mind as I’m dining at New York’s Arthur and Sons. The art on the wall consists of Sinatra and Goodfellas, the wine is flowing, and the food is decidedly red sauce.

The mastermind of star chef Joe Isidori, whose family is behind a multitude of New York Italian eateries of the past, including Villanova Restaurant, a Midtown staple back in the early '60s. Fast forward to the modern era, Arthur and Sons is known for an entire section of the menu dubbed the classics: that is, chicken and veal. And the star of the show here is chicken parm. 

The chicken parm at Arthur & Sons.

Isidori's team pounds the chicken thin, fries it in vegetable oil, and uses Mutti tomatoes for the red sauce. As I devour my dish, I wonder if it'll give me the powers it gave another New York-area Italian...

It was two years ago when Anthony Volpe, a Manhattan-born 24-year-old who grew up in Morristown, New Jersey, started playing for that great baseball team in the Bronx.

A fervent, life-long fan of the Yanks (he even scored a picture with Derek Jeter when he was a kid), Volpe became one of those rare tri-state natives drafted by his hometown team. He hit the ground running, and a legion of Pinstripe fans pinned their hopes on the new kid.

So, where does this praiseworthy parm come into play? 

Well, like a good Italian boy, Volpe invited some teammates over to his house in New Jersey in June 2023. While there, according to Sports Illustrated, they “hung out, dined on chicken parm and reminisced while going over old at-bats.” It was during this red sauce-soaked summit that they noticed something wrong with Volpe’s batting stance that he was, subsequently, able to correct.

With the parm-fueled revelation flowing in his head, Volpe’s numbers exploded on the field. The legend of the “Chicken Parm Boys” was born complete with t-shirts and memes.

The chicken parm at Jr and Son in Brooklyn.
The chicken parm at Jr and Son in Brooklyn.

I’m thinking about the ongoing fandom as I sit down at another place known for parm. Brooklyn’s Jr and Son, which reopened this spring as an ode to old school Italian American food and libations.

During the current season, Volpe’s play, especially at the plate, has fluctuated from red hot to what can fairly be described, at the time of this writing, as cool.

I wonder if Volpe and the boys should pay a visit to Arthur and Sons or Jr and Son for some plates of chicken parm and, perhaps, another breakthrough at home plate.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Appetito

Sammontana Gelato Debuts in the U.S.

Italy’s most beloved gelato brand lands in New York, marking its first-ever U.S. debut with immersive events at Eataly Flatiron and Madison Square Park.

RPZL Partners with Island to East Side on Italian Summer-inspired Hair Clip Collection

Two fashion brands team up to launch a hair clip collection inspired by the ethos and aesthetic of an Italian summer.

June 24, 2025

What to Order at Ficuzza, New York City’s West Village Newcomer

Appetito visits the new Sicilian restaurant Ficuzza in the West Village and shares an overview and some recommendations.

June 23, 2025

Sunday Shop: Newport, RI packing guide 

Morgan Hines seeks out the best in not only food and drink but style, housewares, and more. Welcome to Appetito’s Sunday Shop!

June 22, 2025

How to Channel an Italian Summer…Wherever You Are

Our Health & Wellness expert offers up some practices for an Italian summer for those of us who can't make it to Il Bel Paese.

See all posts