Skip to Content

These Italian Restaurants Made The Times’ 100 Best Restaurants List For 2023

Pasta from Via Carota

The annual list from New York Times restaurant critic Pete Wells features more than a dozen New York City Italian restaurants

The New York Times today released its annual survey of “The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City 2023,” and—spoiler alert—many Italian restaurants made the cut. Restaurant critic Pete Wells calls the list “a guide, based on my decade of reviewing,” and it does focus primarily on restaurants that he has critiqued in the Times’ weekly review. 

What’s surprising about the Italian selections is how narrow they are in terms of chefs. While 14 New York City Italian restaurants made the top 100, four of these are the work of Missy Robbins (Lilia at #17, Misi at #39)  and the Rita Sodi/Jody Williams partnership (Via Carota at #4 and I Sodi at #64). The Major Food Group, the fast-growing team behind Carbone—which began in the West Village before becoming what amounts to an upscale chain—has its latest Italian entry, Torrisi, earning #33. Their Midtown power spot The Grill clocks in at #10.

Two pizza-first spots make the grade, both on the Lower East Side. Una Pizza Napoletana (#15) and Scarr’s (#72). Brooklyn favorites Roberta’s and Lucali, to name only two, aren’t in the mix.

Wells tries to be equitable, in terms of location, with all five boroughs represented, and type of cuisine, which is listed along with each entry. Below are the Italian restaurants, identified as such by The New York Times, featured on the list (behind a paywall, so subscribe if you haven’t already and have the means to do so).

4- Via Carota 

15- Una Pizza Napoletana

17- Lilia

22- King

33- Torrisi

39- Misi

45- Lodi

Pasta dish from Rezdôra
Rezdôra's famed dish "Grandma Walking Through The Forest."

47- Rezdôra

56- Don Peppe Ozone Park

64- I Sodi

67- Mark’s Off Madison

72- Scarr’s Pizza

85- Barbuto

97- Randazzo’s Clam Bar Sheepshead Bay

Already a user?Log in

Thanks for reading!

Register to continue

See all subscription options

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Appetito

How to Make the Meatballs of Frankies Spuntino in Brooklyn

A charming anecdote regarding the origins of the meatballs served at Frankie's Spuntino accompanies this coveted recipe.

April 15, 2024

Brooklyn Restaurant Group Frankies Goes to Nashville

The legendary Brooklyn-based restaurant group has opened a collection of Italian food offerings in Nashville.

April 15, 2024

Join Deborah Dal Fovo in the Food Mecca of Emilia-Romagna

Appetito's contributor, Chef & Cooking Instructor Deborah Dal Fovo, will be leading a food-focused tour of Emilia-Romagna.

April 12, 2024

Talking San Sabino with Angie Rito and Scott Tacinelli

The chefs behind West Village hit Don Angie discuss their brand-new follow-up, the seafood-centric San Sabino, and much more in this Appetito interview.

April 11, 2024
See all posts