Skip to Content
Cocktails

How to Make the Negroni Paradox From Miss Nellie’s

A sweeter, more crushable version of a white Negroni from the eclectic bar Miss Nellie’s in NYC’s Hell’s Kitchen, served with striking red orbs known as “Campari caviar.”

By Sarah Tierney

9:00 AM EST on November 22, 2024

Negron Paradox from Miss Nellie's

The Negroni Paradox from Miss Nellie’s in NYC.

Sarah Tierney created the Negroni Paradox for the cocktail menu at Miss Nellie's, a restaurant and bar in NYC's Hell's Kitchen, near the Theater District and Times Square. Tierney and Andy Flynn develop the drinks for PMac's Hospitality Group, which operates more than a dozen restaurants and cocktail lounges in NYC, including Miss Nellie's. Here, Tierney, describes the cocktail's genesis and shares the recipe. Those bright red orbs? They're "Campari caviar"—see the recipe notes for how to make them using the plant-based gelatin Agar Agar.

The objective was to create a Negroni riff that would appeal to all people. Due to its dry, intense flavor profile, many people would opt for a sweeter, more crushable drink. So I incorporated the Solerno Blood Orange liqueur to add a sweet citrus note, whilst not moving too far from the dry finish. 

A white Negroni was the goal to switch up the classic look but with Suze being a liquor of acquired taste, Luxardo Bitter Bianco seemed a more suitable pairing. Andy made the suggestion of incorporating the Cocchi Americano Bianco to bring us to the perfectly balanced finish.

When people think of Negroni's they immediately think of Campari and its deep crimson color, so why not incorporate it in the garnish? Hence the Campari Agar Agar caviar (which are also quite tasty) . This is also how the name "Negroni Paradox" transpired. It's a paradox to the classic in visual and in taste. 

We asked our staff to describe the cocktail as "A Negroni for people who don't drink Negroni's" and seemingly the feedback has been great. People are surprised with its smooth finish while still maintaining subtle signature notes you would expect from the classic itself. 

[Note: Appetito may earn commissions from products featured in links to this story.]

The Negroni Paradox

The Negroni Paradox

Recipe by Sarah Tierney
5.0 from 2 votes
Servings

1

servings
Prep time

10

minutes
Cooking time

5

minutes

Ingredients

  • 1 Oz 1 Gin (Bombay)

  • 1 Oz 1 Cocchi Americano Bianco

  • 0.75 Oz 0.75 Luxardo Bitter Bianco

  • 0.25 Oz 0.25 Solerno Blood Orange Liqueur

  • Campari Agar Agar Caviar (see note)

Directions

  • Fill a mixing glass with ice.
  • Add gin, Cocchi Americano Bianco, Luxardo Bitter Bianco, and Solerno Blood Orange Liqueur.
  • Stir for about 30 seconds.
  • Strain into a rocks glass over a large ice cube.
  • Garnish with Campari Agar Agar Caviar

Notes

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @appetitomagazine on Instagram and hashtag it with #italianfoodanddrink

Like this recipe?

Follow @Appetitomagazine on Pinterest

Follow us on Facebook!

Follow us on Facebook

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Appetito

Alba Brings Its NYC Roots to the Heart of West Hollywood

Cucina Alba’s West Coast expansion brings handmade pasta and New York polish to a new indoor-outdoor space on Melrose Avenue.

Happy Socks’ New Line Includes a “Love Letter” to Aperol Spritz

A sock wear line celebrates the essence of Italian summers with an item inspired by the iconic Aperol spritz.

May 12, 2025

Sunday Shop: 5 Dresses I Can’t Stop Thinking About

Morgan Hines seeks out the best in not only food and drink but style, housewares, and more. Welcome to Appetito’s Sunday Shop!

May 11, 2025

Italy Meets Wall Street: NEROLAB’s Bold New Home

NEROLAB’s 21,500-square-foot flagship has arrived in the Financial District, blending Roman flavors and Italian hospitality with a sleek, modern setting.

See all posts