Skip to Content
Features

Splashing across Milan for an Old Italian Gem

Our contributor from Parma ventures north for a rain-swept trek across Milan to experience an old gem of a restaurant.

The exterior of Da Martino in Milan.

The exterior of Da Martino in Milan.

Crossing Milan in its gloomy, wet state, we held newspapers over our heads, navigated around puddles, and shared brief moments with the few other souls braving the weather, surely due to some obliged lunch appointment. My partner nodded to a man whose downward-pointing nose steadily dripped raindrops on his cigar, while I felt for a woman whose water-marred overcoat and stockings professed a recent douse from a passing car.

After hearing some buzz about an old gem in Milan, I made a lunch reservation. Its location, a fair distance from where we were staying, paired with the persistent January rain, had us wondering: Is it worth it?

Nonetheless, determination fueled by hunger egged us across the city to Da Martino.

Upon arrival, I was reminded of the call I’d made to the restaurant a few days earlier. A gruff voice had informed me that Da Martino no longer sold pizza by the slice—an old identity, I assume, that the restaurant is in the process of shedding. The door handle, shaped like a cheese pizza, and the dim LED sign in the window—where 'Pizza al trancio' remains unlit, but 'dal 1950' still shines—served as subtle reminders of this transformation.

The menu, however, spoke clearly of freshness and of youth.

Crostini with rabbit pâté and anchovies paired with chickpea fries and chervil oil.
Crostini with rabbit pâté and anchovies paired with chickpea fries and chervil oil.

To start, we chose the crostini with rabbit pâté and the anchovies paired with chickpea fries and chervil oil (an herb akin to parsley, but with delicate hints of tarragon). The anchovy dish was bright and tangy, with a flavor profile that instinctively took me to the Basque country. Judging from the first dishes, the chef was clearly experimental, supposedly taking a strong start in a new direction.

For the primi, we shared the busiate pasta with kale pesto, almonds, and Fiore Sardo, a Sardinian cheese, alongside the tagliatelle alla Genovese finished with Parmigiano di Vacche Rosse. The dishes presented a courageous and skillfully paired, multi-regional Italian cuisine. By this point, my partner knew better than to try speaking—my eyes were closed, and my left hand circled in the air, declaring through my faux-Italian mannerisms that the food was simply too good for words.

Tagliatelle alla Genovese with Parmigiano di Vacche Rosse.
Tagliatelle alla Genovese with Parmigiano di Vacche Rosse.

For the final dish, we dared ourselves to go big or go home, pushing past the creeping fullness to order the cotoletta—a classic Milanese staple that seemed to grace nearly every neighboring table. We decided to share one, our eyes finally catching up to our stomachs. A tenderized veal cutlet, with the bone fried separately, was another dish, another stretch of time passing sans speech, but this time the bite was boastfully Milanese.

Cotoletta Milanese.
Cotoletta Milanese.

Overall, the restaurant presented itself as a casual yet charming spot, serving up good flavors with an adventurous flair. I’m curious to see how its new identity will develop, and I believe it will surely soon attract more gastronomic tourism to the area.

As for us, we will certainly be returning to see its transformation—rain or shine. Da Martino was definitely worth it.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Appetito

Tucci in Italy: Episode 2 Recap

In episode two of "Tucci in Italy," Tucci explores the culinary culture of the northern region of Lombardy.

Campari Spritz Square Pops Up in NYC for One Weekend Only

For one weekend only, Campari brings its signature red cocktail to life with a two-day aperitivo experience in New York’s Chinatown and Lower East Side.

Fabbri 1905, Toscana Tourism & All About Italy Bring Aperitif to NYC

Ten NYC restaurants celebrate Italian Aperitif Week with custom cocktails and Tuscan pairings, thanks to Fabbri 1905, All About Italy, and Toscana Tourism.

Appetito Hosts “Demo & Dine” at Eataly with Guest Joanna Moeller

Appetito announces a cooking and conversation event at Eataly Flatiron with Italian food influencer Joanna Moeller.

June 4, 2025

Chef’s Lab x GALLIM Comes to Refettorio Harlem

Chef’s Lab x GALLIM takes over Refettorio Harlem with a four-course dinner, live dance performance, and a shared mission to feed both body and soul.

See all posts