Skip to Content
Advertisement
News

Appetito Shares a Feast of the Seven Fishes on Good Day New York

Appetito's EIC Andrew Cotto appeared on Good Day New York to share a Feast of the Seven Fishes and to advocate for the embrace by all of Italian cuisine.

11:22 AM EST on December 24, 2025

Appetito's EIC Andrew Cotto with Rosanna Scotto on Good Day New York.

Appetito’s EIC Andrew Cotto with Rosanna Scotto on Good Day New York.

One might think, after seeing Appetito’s Editor-in-Chief Andrew Cotto on Good Day New York this week, that he spent all night preparing a Feast of Seven Fishes for his friend and iconic morning news host Rosanna Scotto.

One might also think that our affable EIC doesn’t know how to count, as the number of fish on display far exceeded the traditional “seven” touted in the promotion.

However, both impressions would be incorrect.

Andrew did not spend all night making the traditional Christmas Eve meal enjoyed by Italian Americans. Instead, he called upon Chef Thomas Joseph Perone of Brooklyn Roots to do the heavy lifting in the kitchen, which he did with extraordinary results and abundance (hence the far >7 tally of fishes).

Even the demo Andrew did of Mussels Marina was cribbed from this recipe from Appetito contributor Danielle Caminiti.

The primary objective of Andrew on Good Day New York was to educate the audience on the traditional holiday and to encourage all to not only embrace this Xmas Eve menu but the entire Italian lifestyle year-round with regard to cuisine.

Andrew recently appeared on the BBC to discuss UNESCO’s formal recognition of Italian cuisine as an Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity. The topic on the BBC, and the general reason for this unique recognition, aligns with a primary mission of Appetito: to persuade people from all backgrounds to come to our Italian table to enjoy the cuisine and each other’s company. The benefits are profound in myriad ways with regard to quality of life. Best part: All are welcome!

This very spirit was on display during Andrew’s joyous visit to Good Day New York, from the backstage prep, to the segment on set, to the feast afterward enjoyed by many staffers at Good Day New York and Fox5 employees on all floors of the building.

Watch the full segment below. Happy Holidays from our family to yours!

More Stories

Fannie Farmer’s 1965 Carbonara

One pound of pasta. One pound of bacon. Green pepper. And an author who’d been dead for fifty years. The 1965 Fannie Farmer carbonara may be one of the strangest carbonara recipes ever.

November 3, 2026

Mangiare in testa a qualcuno: When Superiority Comes with Table Service

In Italian, even an absurd place to eat can make perfect sense.

November 3, 2026

Perfume & Culinary Retreat in Italy: April 2027

Appetito contributor Anita Jozsef is co-organizing a weeklong Perfume & Culinary Retreat with perfumer Franziska Josteit, bringing Scandinavian gastronomy and the art of perfumery together in Civitanova Marche, Italy.

November 2, 2026

The Beauty and Reality of the Slow Season in Italy

Our Sorrento-based contributor reflects on the dawn of the seasonal shift away from the months of rampant tourism in Italy.

November 2, 2026

Sunday Shop: 60 Cozy Women’s Finds for Autumn/Winter 2026 

Morgan Hines seeks out the best in not only food and drink but style, housewares, and more. Welcome to Appetito’s Sunday Shop!

November 1, 2026

On Gremolata and Death: a Halloween Story Starring Parsley

A craving for parsley inspires a recipe for Gremolata and research into the funerary rituals of ancient Rome.

October 30, 2026